The latest Stonehaven planning proposals involve separate supermarket developments led by Tesco and a joint Aldi and M&S Foodhall project. These plans are intended to improve shopping options, create jobs, and support future growth while meeting local planning requirements.
Overview of the Stonehaven Planning Proposals
Stonehaven has been the focus of several major retail planning proposals. The two main developments include:
| Proposal | Main Details | Current Status |
|---|---|---|
| Tesco Stonehaven Gateway | New full size Tesco supermarket with supporting facilities | Revised planning application submitted |
| Aldi and M&S Ury Estate | Shared retail development with Aldi and M&S Foodhall | Planning application submitted following commercial agreement |
Both proposals aim to improve grocery shopping choices for local residents while supporting future housing and commercial development in the area.
Tesco Stonehaven Planning Proposal
Tesco has submitted updated plans for a new supermarket at Stonehaven Gateway after an earlier proposal faced planning challenges.
The revised proposal includes:
- A large supermarket designed for weekly food shopping
- Electric vehicle charging facilities
- Customer parking
- New employment opportunities
- Improved access for local shoppers
According to the planning documents, the development is expected to create around 100 jobs if approved. Tesco also updated its retail impact studies and local shopping data to support the latest application.
Why Tesco Resubmitted Its Plans
The original proposal received objections because of concerns about its possible impact on Stonehaven town centre businesses.
Tesco’s revised application includes updated evidence that aims to show:
- Strong demand for a larger supermarket
- Reduced travel for local grocery shopping
- Better retail choice for residents
- Economic benefits through new jobs and investment
Public consultation also showed significant support for improved supermarket options within the town.
Aldi and M&S Ury Estate Development
A separate retail project has been proposed for the Ury Estate development.
The project brings together Aldi and M&S Foodhall in one retail building while maintaining separate stores inside.
The proposal includes:
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Aldi store | Approximately 1,647 square metres gross floor area |
| M&S Foodhall | Approximately 2,286 square metres gross floor area |
| Parking | 373 parking spaces |
| Main focus | Convenience food shopping with limited comparison goods |
Most of the retail space in both stores is planned for food and grocery products.
Planning History of the Ury Estate Site
The Ury Estate has already received planning permission for supermarket development in previous years.
Following changes in commercial agreements, developers submitted updated plans naming Aldi and M&S as the intended retailers.
The revised application keeps much of the approved site layout while updating the buildings and retail operators. Developers have stated that the project fits within the wider Ury Estate masterplan, which also includes housing and other community facilities.
Community Consultation and Local Feedback
Community consultation has played an important role throughout the planning process.
The Stonehaven and District Community Council conducted surveys to understand local views on supermarket proposals.
Key findings included:
- Many residents complete their main grocery shopping outside Stonehaven.
- There is strong interest in having additional supermarket choices.
- Residents want better access to larger food stores closer to home.
Community feedback is one factor considered alongside planning policy, traffic studies, environmental reports, and retail impact assessments.
Economic Benefits of the Proposed Developments
If approved and completed, the developments could provide several economic benefits.
Potential advantages include:
- New full time and part time jobs
- Increased local investment
- Better retail competition
- Reduced travel for grocery shopping
- Support for growing residential areas
Retail developments may also encourage additional commercial investment in surrounding areas as population growth continues.
Planning Considerations
Planning authorities typically assess several factors before making decisions on large retail developments.
These include:
| Planning Factor | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| Traffic impact | Road capacity and vehicle movement |
| Town centre impact | Effect on existing businesses |
| Environmental considerations | Landscaping, drainage, and sustainability |
| Employment | Local job creation |
| Community need | Demand for additional retail facilities |
Both Tesco and the Aldi M&S proposals include supporting reports addressing these planning considerations.
Differences Between the Tesco and Aldi M&S Plans
| Tesco Proposal | Aldi and M&S Proposal |
|---|---|
| Single large supermarket | Two retailers sharing one building |
| Stonehaven Gateway site | Ury Estate site |
| Around 100 expected jobs | Integrated retail development supporting the Ury Estate masterplan |
| Includes EV charging facilities | Includes 373 parking spaces |
| Focus on one retailer | Combined Aldi discount store and M&S Foodhall |
Both projects are separate planning applications and are considered independently by the planning authority.
Possible Community Impact
If one or both developments proceed, residents could experience:
- More grocery shopping choices
- Less travel to nearby towns for weekly shopping
- Additional local employment
- Greater retail competition
- Improved convenience for new housing developments
Planning authorities also continue to assess how these projects may affect existing town centre retailers and the overall balance of local commerce.
Current Status of Tesco Aldi M&S Stonehaven Planning
The latest planning position shows two active retail proposals.
Tesco has submitted an updated application for a new supermarket at Stonehaven Gateway with revised supporting evidence following earlier planning objections.
Separately, Aldi and M&S have reached agreements for a shared retail development at the Ury Estate. Updated planning documents outline store layouts, parking, landscaping, and supporting infrastructure as part of the wider masterplan.
